For homeowners, replacing a roof can feel like a big decision in itself. There are so many considerations to think about, including durability (a particularly big factor for withstanding the winds and rain in Florida), aesthetics, and matching styles with the rest of the home's exterior.

Maybe for aesthetic reasons, you've narrowed your roofing choice down to some form of tile. But do you want clay roof tiles or concrete roof tiles, and what are the differences between clay and concrete tile when it comes to roofing? It's a legitimate question, because the two types of tiles look similar, and homeowners often confuse the two upon first glance. The tiled roof style is very popular in Florida, especially in Spanish mission-style homes, so you've likely seen many in your neck of the woods.

But how can you decide between clay and concrete roof tiles? What are the major differences between clay and concrete, and which makes sense for your home and budget? Let's take a comprehensive look at the pros and cons of concrete versus clay roof tiles so that you can decide which may be right for your Florida home.

What are the pros and cons of concrete vs. clay roofs?

Both concrete and clay roof tiles are attractive and perform well long-term, especially compared with other roofing materials such as asphalt shingles. Clay tile roofs are the most popular type of roofing in Florida because they have numerous benefits. What you might not realize is that concrete tile shares the benefits of clay tile and has a few more to boot.

Here's a look at the pros of roofing with clay or concrete roof tiles:

Pros of clay and concrete roof tiles

  • They last the lifetime of the home. Clay roof tiles are very low-maintenance once installed, and they last 25-30 years or more. Because of the long lifespans and the low maintenance requirements for roofs made of these materials, they're economical choices in the long run and, in turn, they're beneficial to the home's resale value.
  • Clay and concrete roof tiles offer Class A fire-rated protection, so they safeguard your home in the event of a fire and are typically eligible for the lowest fire insurance premiums.
  • Both concrete and clay roof tiles can sustain high winds of 150 to 180 mph, which is important for weathering tropical storms and hurricanes in South Florida.
  • Clay and concrete roof tiles also hold up well to the Florida heat, its intense weather patterns, and pests and insects.
  • Whether clay or concrete, roofing tiles are available in myriad colors and styles. Both concrete and clay roof tiles come in a wide variety of sizes, colors, and shapes, so they can be made to match your home's architectural style, no matter what era or inspiration. Roof tiles can even resemble wood shakes, distressed slate, or centuries-old roofs. No matter your home's aesthetic, concrete or clay roof tiles can fit right in.
  • They maintain their color over time. Even in the Florida sun, their color may soften over time, but it won't easily fade. Some clay roof tile manufacturers provide up to 50-year guarantees against color fading.
  • Maintenance needs are limited with clay and concrete tile roof. The roof's venting, protrusion flashings, and gutters will still require attention, but tile roofs avoid the painting, sealing, and cleaning needs that many roof materials require.

Additional Pros of concrete tile roofs

  • They're lighter in weight than clay tile roofs, so they bear less weight on the home's structure and create less strain over the years. While they are heavier than some materials, such as asphalt shingles, they're also more durable.
  • Concrete roofing tiles are cheaper than clay tiles, costing up to 30% less.

How much do clay vs. concrete tile roofs cost?

The prices of concrete and clay tile roofs will vary by region, roof size, slope, and the number of roof lines on your home, so experts say it's best to get at least four quotes from contractors before making a final decision and having your roof replaced. At Latite Roofing, we're ready to offer you a free quote anytime; call 1-800-639-7663 (NEW-ROOF) for more information.